My Views on the (Misnamed) “Ground Zero Mosque”

What is it exactly?

Many of the opponents to the new Islamic center that is to be built in Manhattan  have misleadingly been using the term “Ground Zero mosque” and have even been saying that the mosque is being built right on Ground Zero, as if it is to be built exactly where the World Trade Center once stood. That should be the first misperception that is cleared up. (The original name was The Cordoba House and it is now being called Park51, for its address).

Another misperception is that the building itself will be only a mosque. I can see where those who are wary of Islam would object to a 13-story mosque, no matter where it was built. It’s just too threatening and smacks of being some kind of monument to Islam, instead of merely a place to worship. Opponents usually refuse to address the fact that the proposed building is only to have a mosque in it; the rest of it will be given over to community-oriented activities and will be open to everyone, not just to Muslims.

Doubt about its purpose

People who refuse to believe that a religious center (specifically a Muslim one) would be open to all people regardless of their religion, forget that another organization known for its community centers is the YMCA, which stands for “Young Men’s Christian Association.” It was founded on Christian principles, yet its community centers have been used widely since the middle of the nineteenth century by people of all faiths.

Skeptics also conveniently overlook the existence of Jewish community centers, which are also open to the general public. No one is afraid that these centers are going to try to convert everyone who uses them to Christianity or Judaism. They exist to serve the needs of the community. That’s what Park51 wants to do, if its opponents will allow it.

Some people believe that Park51 is going to be a breeding ground for terrorists. Why? Just because it is near Ground Zero? (That would be kind of stupid of the terrorists, wouldn’t it?) Or is that what they think about any mosque or Islamic center? If so, then their objections seem to be based more on paranoia and prejudice against Muslims than on anything else. Their argument is related to the belief that “all Muslims are terrorists,” which is patently not true.

Hallowed ground

One reason opponents object to the Islamic center is that they consider Ground Zero to be “hallowed ground.” Again, Park51 is not being built on Ground Zero. But I challenge the idea that it is hallowed ground. Yes, a terrible tragedy occurred there. But terrible tragedies have happened in many places; are we to designate them all as sacred?

Some people consider even the area around Ground Zero to be sacred, because the remains of victims settled on the streets and buildings for many blocks. But how many blocks can you claim as sacred before the idea becomes unrealistic? Four blocks? Six? Ten? All of Manhattan? And does it follow that a mosque can’t be built anywhere the ashes fell?

There are many who think that any mosque is an affront to the American people and they would have them banned everywhere. So what about Muslims themselves? Do they want them banned from the U.S. because of what happened on 9/11? If they were honest, that’s probably exactly what they want.

Muslim opponents

Some Muslims have sided with the conservatives, Islamophobes and yes, grieving relatives, about whether or not a mosque should be built near Ground Zero. Their reasons are 1) that Muslims should always do whatever leads to peace; and 2) that Muslims should be sensitive to those who lost loved ones on September 11, 2001 and not do anything to exacerbate their pain.

First of all, Muslims are supposed to seek peace. But not at all costs. Muslims have a right to practice their religion and a mandate from God to pray five times a day. Those who seek to make it hard for Muslims to do so should be resisted, even if it makes Muslims look difficult. Keeping the peace does not mean giving in to everyone who disagrees with you. Peace can only come through understanding and tolerance. Muslims are not being intolerant when they establish a place for their own worship. If that were the case, then every church and synagogue is also a symbol of intolerance.

Also, how are non-Muslims ever going to understand Muslims if they are never exposed to them? In my opinion, there should be more mosques and Islamic centers and Muslims should not be afraid to practice or speak about their faith. The more Muslims try to stay in the background, the less chance non-Muslims have to get to know them. I think the opponents of Park51 (as well as other mosques around the country) would be surprised by how much Muslims can add to the community.  But for that to happen, Muslims need to make an effort to be involved in the community and not stay locked up in their own.

Caring about others

This, too, is a mandate from God. We are set on this earth to worship Him and serve His creation. A Muslim is to always care for the needs of others. But there have to be other ways to be sensitive without doing away with an Islamic center. If anything, such a center would show the world that Muslims do care and want to be a source of healing. The presence of Park51 may seem hurtful at first, but given time and effort on the part of Muslims, it can also be a place where non-Muslims can go to find out more about Islam and perhaps learn to forgive.

I understand that this topic is sensitive right now, but that’s partly because those who oppose Islam are whipping it up into a media sensation. After all, it has been nine years since 9/11. Isn’t it about time to start building bridges between the non-Muslim and the Muslim worlds? Further antagonism only serves the purposes of people like Bin Laden. Whenever Muslims and the West can’t get along, critics of the West use that as proof that the West should be obliterated. If the terrorists are shown that the West and Islam can coexist peacefully, then what reasons will they have for continuing to hate and target the West? If they no longer have fuel for their fire, then the flames will eventually die out.

An opportunity for healing

I feel for the families of the victims of 9/11. I do. But healing doesn’t come from keeping the object of your anger out of the picture. It only comes when there is honest dialogue between the aggrieved and those whom they are having trouble forgiving. This isn’t easy, but it’s part of the healing process. Maybe it’s a good thing that non-Muslims are protesting the Islamic center so vigorously right now. It gives Muslims the chance to speak about how they themselves feel about 9/11 and Islamophobia. When someone is being criticized, he or she has the right and, in America, the opportunity, to set the record straight.

Park51 gives Muslims the opportunity to squarely face their accusers. We need to take this opportunity and make the most of it.

Published by

Ellen

Editor and chief writer at I, Muslimah and Femagination. Ellen also contributes regularly to Elevate Difference. She is a freelance writer, essayist and copy editor, living with two cats and a husband in Columbus, OH.